949.945.0025 Appointment

Botox vs. Xeomin: Comparing Effectiveness and Benefits

Published by Dr. Brandon Richland, MD

In the world of cosmetic treatments, two leading names that often come up are Xeomin and Botox. Both are injectable neurotoxins, which have been approved by health authorities to treat fine lines, and treat certain muscle-related conditions.

While the active ingredient in both is botulinum toxin type A, their formulations, usage, and effects have nuanced differences that can influence a patient’s choice of treatment. Patients and practitioners alike weigh various factors–from onset of action to longevity of results–when deciding between Xeomin and Botox.

Understanding how Xeomin and Botox work is crucial for those considering treatment. Both injectables temporarily paralyze muscles by blocking the release of a chemical that causes muscle contraction, resulting in smoother skin. However, the presence or absence of complexing proteins in each solution can make a significant difference in an individual’s response to treatment.

Key Takeaways of Botox vs. Xeomin

  • Xeomin and Botox are botulinum toxin type A injectables used for cosmetic and medical purposes.
  • They differ in formulation and potential patient responses to treatment.
  • Choice between the two should consider factors like duration, cost, side effects, and individual health.

Understanding Botulinum Toxin

Botulinum toxin is a highly potent neurotoxin that is utilized for both therapeutic and cosmetic purposes. It’s crucial to understand its history and the different types available, such as Xeomin and Botox, which have specific applications and characteristics.

Image Credit: Yacobchuk / 123RF.com (Licensed).

Types of Botulinum Toxin

Botulinum toxin comes in several different formulations. The most widely known types:

  • Botulinum toxin type A: Predominantly used in cosmetic and medical treatments.
  • Incobotulinumtoxina (trade name Xeomin): A purified form of botulinum toxin type A without accessory proteins.
  • Onabotulinumtoxina (trade name Botox): Contains the same active molecule as Xeomin but has additional proteins surrounding it.

These different formulations allow providers to tailor treatments to individual needs and responses.

Botox and Xeomin Overview

Xeomin and Botox are two FDA-approved injectable neurotoxins widely employed for cosmetic and medical purposes. They share similarities in usage but differ in composition and some aspects of their application.

Defining Xeomin

Xeomin, often referred to as the “naked injectable,” is a brand of botulinum toxin type A. It is characterized by its absence of complexing proteins, meaning it contains only the pure neurotoxin without any additives.

This may reduce the likelihood of developing resistance to the treatment. Xeomin’s FDA-approved uses span various muscle-related conditions and cosmetic improvements of facial wrinkles.

Defining Botox

Botox is a widely recognized brand of botulinum toxin that has been utilized for over two decades. Like Xeomin, Botox is FDA-approved and serves a range of both therapeutic and aesthetic functions.

It differs from Xeomin in that it includes protective proteins surrounding the neurotoxin, which may influence its interaction with the immune system. Botox is heralded for its efficacy in smoothing facial lines and treating muscle disorders.

Comparing Xeomin and Botox Treatment

When considering treatments for reducing the appearance of wrinkles caused by movement, also called dynamic wrinkles, Xeomin and Botox are two prevalent options. They work similarly but have a few key differences that might influence an individual’s choice.

Efficacy and Results

Xeomin and Botox are both FDA-approved for cosmetic use, with each having a strong record of temporarily reducing the appearance of facial lines. Research suggests they have comparable effectiveness, with a 1-to-1 dosing ratio. However, individual responses can vary, and one may work better than the other for some people.

  • Botox Injections: FDA Approved Uses
    • Cosmetic: Treat frown lines, forehead lines, crow’s feet, and wrinkles.
    • Therapeutic: Chronic migraines, excessive underarm sweating, strabismus, and more.
  • Xeomin: FDA Approved Uses
    • Cosmetic: Frown lines between the eyebrows.
    • Therapeutic: Cervical dystonia, eyelid spasms.

Onset and Duration

The onset of Xeomin’s effects can take up to 4 days to fully manifest, while Botox typically shows results in about 72 hours. In terms of duration, both treatments last approximately 3-6 months. The speed of onset and the length of time the effects last can be factors in choosing between the two treatments.

Side Effects and Risks

The side effects associated with Xeomin and Botox are similar, with potential risks including redness, swelling, or bruising at the injection site. Rarely, one might experience allergic reactions or other more serious side effects like problems with breathing or swallowing.

Xeomin is a purified form of botulinum toxin type A and does not contain complexing proteins, which theoretically could lead to a reduced risk of developing antibodies that could make the treatment less effective over time.

Procedure Overview

Both Xeomin and Botox are minimally invasive injectables approved by the FDA for reducing the appearance of facial wrinkles. During the treatment process, a healthcare provider will apply topical numbing cream, after that carefully inject the neurotoxin into the targeted muscles that cause wrinkles.

  • Pre-treatment: Typically no extensive preparation is needed.
  • During treatment: Patients may feel a slight pinch or pain at the injection site.

Cost and Insurance

When considering cosmetic procedures like Xeomin and Botox, potential patients often evaluate the financial aspects closely. Cosmetic treatment expenses can vary while insurance coverage for these procedures is usually limited.

Treatment Expenses

Xeomin and Botox treatments involve costs that may include the price per unit of the product, provider fees, and the number of units required for the desired effect.

The average cost for Xeomin treatments is around $450, but the range can be $250 – $841 depending on many factors, including geographic location and provider credentials. Botox treatments have similar pricing structures but may be on the higher end due to broader FDA-approved uses.

Insurance Coverage

Generally, insurance companies, including Medicare, do not cover cosmetic uses of Xeomin and Botox. However, there are instances where these treatments may be covered if they are for medical conditions such as cervical dystonia or severe underarm sweating.

Patients should check with their insurance provider to understand the coverage options, as some plans might cover a portion of the cost for medically necessary procedures.

Practical Considerations

When comparing Xeomin and Botox, patients and providers should consider the nuances of storage, handling, and treatment schedules. These elements are critical for ensuring the effectiveness and safety of the injections.

Image Credit: Akkamulator / 123RF.com (Licensed).

Storage and Handling

Xeomin has an advantage when it comes to storage requirements. Unlike Botox, which requires refrigeration before reconstitution, Xeomin does not need to be kept refrigerated, simplifying the storage and distribution process.

Once reconstituted, both products require refrigeration to maintain their integrity. Providers must follow strict guidelines to ensure that the neurotoxins are stored at optimal temperatures to preserve their potency.

Frequency of Treatments

Both Xeomin and Botox typically require follow-up injections every three to six months to maintain the desired effects. The specific dosage and frequency can vary depending on individual patient needs and the condition being treated.

Providers generally determine the best treatment plan on a case-by-case basis, considering factors like the patient’s response to previous treatments and the severity of the condition. It’s important for patients to adhere to their provider’s recommended schedule to achieve the best results.

Understanding Side Effects

When discussing Xeomin and Botox, it’s important to consider their safety profiles. Both treatments may cause some side effects, most of which are mild and temporary.

Common Adverse Reactions

The most frequent side effects associated with both Xeomin and Botox are related to the site of injection. Patients may experience:

  • Bruising: Small bruises may appear where the needle was injected but typically resolve quickly.
  • Swelling and redness: These are common responses as the body reacts to the injection.
  • Pain: Some individuals report mild discomfort during and shortly after the procedure.
  • Headache: A temporary headache is possible following the treatment.
  • Itching: The skin around the injection site might itch, but this should subside swiftly.

Additionally, patients undergoing treatment for specific conditions like migraines might find relief from their chronic symptoms post-procedure.

Potential Complications

While uncommon, there are more serious complications that can occur with both Xeomin and Botox, including:

  • Muscle weakness: Difficulties in muscle control might appear, but they are generally temporary.
  • Dry mouth: Some patients may experience less saliva production.
  • Neck pain: Particularly in treatments for certain medical conditions, there might be discomfort in the neck area.
  • Dry eye: Those receiving injections near the eye could notice reduced eye lubrication.

These systemic reactions are less frequent but require monitoring. Patients should always inform their healthcare provider of any continuing or worrisome symptoms post-treatment.

Frequently Asked Questions About Botox vs. Xeomin

1. What Are The Cost Differences Between Xeomin and Botox for Treatment?

Individuals considering these treatments will find that the cost can vary based on provider, location, and required dosage. On average, Botox and Xeomin may have similar pricing, but promotional offers or loyalty programs may influence the final cost.

2. Can You Compare The Duration of Effects Between Xeomin and Botox?

Both Xeomin and Botox are known to offer results that typically last between 3 to 6 months. The effects’ duration can depend on the treated area, the person’s metabolism, and the number of units used.

3. What Should First-Time Users Know About Choosing Between Xeomin and Botox?

First-time users should consult with a licensed professional to understand which product aligns best with their treatment goals and medical history, as both products have a track record of safety and efficacy for various cosmetic and medical conditions.

Image Credit: Lenetstan / 123RF.com (Licensed).

Conclusion and Summary of Botox vs. Xeomin: Comparing Effectiveness and Benefits

In the evolving field of cosmetic treatments, Xeomin and Botox stand out as prominent options for those seeking to mitigate the signs of aging and address specific medical conditions through the targeted use of botulinum toxin type A.

Both treatments share a common goal: to smooth wrinkles and improve the appearance of the skin by temporarily paralyzing muscle activity. Yet, they differ in formulation, potential for immune response, and certain application nuances, making the choice between them reliant on individual patient needs, preferences, and medical history.

The choice between Xeomin and Botox ultimately hinges on a collaborative decision between patient and healthcare provider, taking into account the unique characteristics of each product, the patient’s health profile, treatment goals, and potential for long-term satisfaction with the results.

Patients are encouraged to engage in thorough discussions with their healthcare providers, exploring all aspects of treatment, including expected outcomes, possible side effects, and the overall treatment experience. By doing so, individuals can make informed choices that align with their aesthetic goals and health considerations, ensuring satisfaction with their treatment choice in the pursuit of a more youthful, revitalized and a wrinkle free skin appearance.

Please note that this article is intended for informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice. Before making any changes to your treatments, please consult with your healthcare provider to discuss the appropriateness and safety of such changes.

Ready For Your First-Class Cosmetic Experience in Orange County (OC) California (CA)?

Are you located in one of these Orange County (OC) / Southern California cities?

Aliso Viejo, Anaheim, Brea, Buena Park, Costa Mesa, Coto de Caza, Cypress, Dana Point, Fountain Valley, Fullerton, Garden Grove, Huntington Beach, Irvine, La Habra, La Palma, Laguna Beach, Laguna Hills, Laguna Niguel, Laguna Woods, Ladera Ranch, Lake Forest, Los Alamitos, Mission Viejo, Newport Beach, Orange, Placentia, Rancho Santa Margarita, San Clemente, San Juan Capistrano, Santa Ana, Seal Beach, Stanton, Tustin, Villa Park, Westminster, or Yorba Linda?

Plastic Surgeon Dr. Brandon Richland, MD and our Cosmetic Aesthetics Team are ready to help you look and feel your absolute best.

Elevate your confidence and self esteem levels to unfathomable new heights!

Schedule your in-person consultation in our modern and luxurious offices in either Fountain Valley, CA (Main HQ) or our Newport Beach, CA office. 

Do you live outside of Southern California or short on time? For your convenience, Virtual Consultations are also available.

Our warm and engaging Team of carefully selected Aesthetics Professionals will make you feel calm, cool, collected, and right at home throughout your entire consultation and surgery process.

Schedule Your Aesthetics Consultation here, or call us directly at 714-241-0646 or 949-945-0025 today.

About the Author

Dr. Brandon Richland, MD is a respected Board Certified Licensed Plastic Surgeon in Orange County / Southern California specializing in cosmetic and reconstructive surgeries.

Driven by his passion for medicine, Dr. Richland obtained his Doctor of Medicine (M.D.) degree from the prestigious program at Saint Louis University (SLU) School of Medicine in 2013. His exceptional skills were recognized when he received the McGraw Hill / Lange Medical Student Academic Achievement Award, and graduated top of his class with Honors. For his undergraduate degree, he attended University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and graduated with Honors in 2009.

To further enhance his surgical expertise, Dr. Richland completed his Residency in Plastic Surgery at the University of California, Irvine (UCI) from 2013 to 2019 earning the Academic Achievement Award twice during this period. A total of 14 years in dedicated schooling and medical residency.

Dr. Richland is actively involved with healthcare and medical societies, as a Diplomate of the American Board of Plastic Surgery, a member of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, American Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons, and the California Society of Plastic Surgeons.

Contact Dr. Richland today by visiting RichlandMD.com, scheduling a cosmetic consultation, or by calling 714-241-0646 or 949-945-0025 directly.